Let's look at how Black Canary met (and later joined) the Justice Society of America (JSA) in a little story called "History's Crime Wave!" (All-Star Comics #38).
So, it starts with everyone in the JSA being murdered.
No, really.
![]() |
| Dr Mid-Nite falls to his death. That de-escalated quickly! |
![]() |
| The Atom is clubbed to death. |
![]() |
| The Flash takes a short walk off a long pier. Okay, he was actually SHOT, but there's no joke there. |
![]() |
| Green Lantern is poisoned, and you have to appreciate the irony of GL dying because somebody shoved a ring in his mouth. |
![]() |
| Hawkman is scimitarred (and feathered). |
![]() |
| Johnny has his brain bashed in, which takes a while because you have to find it first. |
We are treated to six identical scenes in which historical villains murder each of the (then current) six (male) JSA members. One of the major downsides of Golden Age JSA stories is that whatever happens with one of the JSAers has to happen to ALL of them. Equality is not a feature of the JSA; it's a flaw.
Dr. Mid-Nite is killed by Emperor Nero, Green Lanter by Cesar Borgia, the Flash by Captain Kidd, the Atom by Goliath, Hawkman by Genghis Khan, Johnny Thunder by Attila the Hun.
The scenes (which are all about two-pages) go as follows: a citizen is being accused of murder in a public place, but swears the murder was actually committed by a long-dead historical villain (an assertion the authorities do not believe).
Then a JSAer shows up, out the blue, as does the historical villain in question, who then kills the JSAer.
NO, REALLY.
![]() |
| Guessing Dr. M never fought The Fiddler. |
![]() |
| You have to appreciate the appropriateness of having the Atom face off against Goliath. |
![]() |
| Guess who's NOT faster than a speeding bullet? |
![]() |
| No one expects the Italian Renaissance! |
![]() |
| Sounds like Genghis converted to Islam at some point after he died. |
The JSAers are all dead. Not a hoax. Not an imaginary story. Only Johnny Thunder hangs in long enough to tell one of his supporting characters --Black Canary--where the JSA HQ is and how to get in.
At this point, the JSA's headquarters was a secret location, apparently; news to me! Sure enough, the narration box confirms the JSA HQ is secretly located.
![]() |
| Wonder Woman, future Parliamentarian of the Justice League, does not tolerate tardiness. "We were NEVER tardy on Paradise Island! Tardy people must be SPANKED!" |
BC shows up at HQ and the only (surviving) member of the JSA is there: Wonder Woman.
So the ladies have to save the day (the day when all the gentlemen are killed). They collect the corpses and cart them to Paula Von Gunther's lab, where she brings them back to life with the Purple Ray, because, well, that's just the kind of thing that happens in a Wonder Woman story.
![]() |
| Why weren't THEY in the Black Lantern crossover?! The whole JSA used to be DEAD. |
WW and BC bundle the Justice Society of Corpses into the Invisible Plane and flies them to "Paula's Laboratory".
![]() |
| Although it is not elaborated on in the story, "Paula" is Paula Von Gunther, the Nazi spy and scientist whose Golden Age character arc had her reform and become tech support for the Amazons. |
Paula does, in fact, bring the JSAers back to life, because that is just the kind of thing that happens in Wonder Woman stories, especially in the Golden Age.
![]() |
| Oh, I know EXACTLY where this is headed. |
Now is your chance to guess what the revivied (male) JSAers do, immediately upon being pried loose from the icy jaws of death?
A. Thank the three ladies profusely for the heroic efforts they made to miraculously revive them;B. Debrief one another on what led them to this state and collectively develop a coordinated response plan;C. Spend time with their loved ones and family, having been sobered by the realization that their lives could be taken from them at any moment;D. Develop protocols to prevent any of the members from engaging in dangerous missions solo, in the hopes of safeguarding against another such incident.
The answer, as I am sure you realize, is E. None of the above. As soon as the JSAers come back to life, they do what any MAN would do.
![]() |
| I am sure if you guess this if you have ever read a JSA story. Or known a man. |
They run out the door to confront the historical villains who killed them.
![]() |
| Because collaboration and planning are for wussies. |
So, to me, the sad part here is not that they do this. It's that it is probably meant to show that they are Men of Action, especially after they've been lying around dead for an afternoon (or two; or more; it's really not clear how long their bodies have been dead and rotting and I don't want to know). Besides, they are JSAers and all they really need to get going are ASSIGNMENTS, which in this situation are ready-made!
Turns out, they are all headed to the same place.
![]() |
| Well, at least that will save us some narrative time. |
To a wax museum, where they confront the unnamed Security Guard.
![]() |
| A somewhat Kirbyesque unnamed security guard, I might add. |
Apparently, the brain takes a little longer than the rest of the body to re-engage, because they all demand to see their respective killers.
![]() |
| I really hate when they chain-talk like this. |
Naturally, the unnamed security guard thinks they are nuts.
![]() |
| You'd think the costumes would have been his first clue. |
He obligingly takes them to confront those villains who are, of course, just an exhibit at the wax museum
Sheepishly, the JSAers come to their senses a bit.
![]() |
| Not just to the guard, Alan. |
All of this has taken 22 pages so far, which is a shockingly large page-count to waste on such nonsense but a shockingly small number of pages to be able to get this much plot in. That's kind of the standard M.O. for Golden Age stories, really.
Fortunately, Black Canary shows up, unimpeded by any Y chromosomes, to help them think it through (since that's not their strength).
![]() |
| "How did I get here? I have a motorcycle, you moron; do you even read your own stories?" |
The JSAers chivalrously decide to indulge the person who literally brought them all back from the dead an hour ago; they are gentlemen, after all. So, Green Lantern chooses the least natural option for holding a group debriefing and flies them all away on a step of glowing great stairs.
![]() |
| "Lantern likes to do things in a big way!" I am so sure, Mary. |
Couldn't they go to a rooftop like normal crimefighters or even just to a coffee shop?
![]() |
| It happens, you know. |
Turns out, as if they were a group of college frat boys, they had all visited the wax musuem together recently.
![]() |
| Why are you wasting your time like this? Is there NO CRIME IN YOUR ERA?! |
There, they lightly dissed the old-school villains.
Green Lantern slowly remembers what happened later: he got a Mysterious Letter inviting him to meet Cesare Borgia at a Certain Location. He ignored it, as any sensible person would; and who is more sensible than a man in a purple cape? But then when he hears a murder was committed at that Certain Location, he goes there only to find Cesare Borgia in the flesh, who kills him with the element of surprise.
![]() |
| Mercifully, the rest of JSAers simply say, "yeah, that's what happened to me, too", sparing us five more identical recaps. |
Black Canary, who fights crime dressed as a cigarette-girl, is also sensible and helps the boys realize how unbelievable their stories sound. But THEN they remember; they all still have the letters they were sent!
OR DO THEY?
![]() |
| The notes suddenly disappear before their very eyes! Just as the caption says. |
Oh, if only one or more of them were scientists or detectives and could puzzle out what just happened.
An aside: I work along the National Mall in Washington, D.C. It looks very nice on TV (and in reality!). But what you don't realize until you are there in person is the SCALE of it: it is lined with buildings EACH OF WHICH is a block long. So everything looks likes it's RIGHT THERE. You can see it!
To put this picture into some perpsective for you: see that little building near the Capitol Building?
![]() |
| This little building? Near the Capitol? It CONTAINS A TROPICAL RAIN FOREST. |
![]() |
| With its own bridges. |
But it takes FOREVER to get from one place to another, and, unlike walking in a regular downtown area, the scenery changes almost not at all so you just feel like you are walking endlessly and getting nowhere. It's exhausting, puzzling, and sometimes dizzying and you feel like sitting down on a bench until it stops.
After 27 pages, the boys are as enervated by all this craziness (which, remember, includes them being murdered) as tourists on the Mall.
![]() |
| You're sitting on a park bench with no one around. Is WHISPERING really called for? |
And this is literally the next panel:
![]() |
| Confused? I am. Let's go sit on a park bench. |
Fortunately, I am well enough versed in Golden Age writing to know what's going on here. Placing false information in a newspaper to provoke a villain to react is a classic tactic of the era. Black Canary had the idea of hiring thugs to play the Historical Villains in re-enactments of the crimes in order to draw out whoever is really posing as the Historical Villains.
![]() |
| Naturally, it works. It ALWAYS works. |
![]() |
| Criminals are a vain and conceited lot. |
STILL the JSAers is no match for the Historical Villain who escapes by... turning into a wax statue, it seems.
![]() |
| Gotta admit, it's a pretty unique gimmick. |
All this makes zero sense, but you get five more chances to ponder it, since this happens again with each of the other heroes and their Historical Villains.
![]() |
| This is a synopsis panel. Each of these encounters takes two or three pages. |
Having been beaten (again) by the Historical Villains, the JSAers find themselves in the 2005 version of "House of Wax".
![]() |
| Where is Paris Hilton when you need her? |
They can't escape the death-trap because the wax has countered all their powers (don't ask) and (as always) everyone forgets that Johnny Thunder has an all-powerful genie at his beck and call. What IS the point Johnny Thunder?
![]() |
| Oh, right; it's his hot-AF sleeper-build. |
There, lording it over them, are the Historical Villains!
Okay, enough is enough. It's time for Fred to pull the mask off these phantom figures and reveal them to be unscrupulous real estate developers.
![]() |
| Okay, fine; Fred is indisposed, so the villain pulls his OWN mask off. A bit like Vincent Price in the 1953 "House of Wax" (in 3D!). |
Turns out all the Historical Villain were the same person: the unnamed Security Guard at the Wax Museum.
![]() |
| Oh, but it IS. |
Yes. A ticked off unnamed museum security guard single-handedly killed off the ENTIRE Justice Society of American (one by one).
![]() |
| He appears to be stronger AND smarter than each of the JSAers. smh |
Yeah. A grouchy unnamed museum guard killed the entire (male) JSA. All while Wonder Woman is fighting all of Nazi Germany, opposing the literal God of War, and casually bringing people back from the dead.
As I have emphasized before, Wonder Woman wasn't "relegated to being the JSA's secretary because she was considered inferior to the men." Wonder Woman, a very popular character who was carrying two titles at the time, had to be LIMITED in her participation in the JSA, because she made them look so bad by comparison.
Anyway, the helpless JSAers are all about to be killed by an addlepated unnamed security guard when they are saved by...
LUCREZIA BORGIA!
Okay, you get ZERO points for figuring out who Lucrezia really is.
The guard's violent overreaction proves to be his undoing.
![]() |
| Oops. |
Not really sure why the vat of wax kills the security guard and not the JSAers. I suppose falling in head-first doesn't help.
Canary frees Flash, who frees the others.
Who finally acknowledge that Black Canary has just saved their lives. Twice.
Black Canary then passive-aggressively Cinderellas herself off-stage, heading back to her flower shop.
![]() |
| "I'll just go home and have a dinner of bitter vetch and wormwood." |
But then the story ends with the JSA making Black Canary...
... an "honorary guest"?! What a bunch of ingrates!
Actually, the situation rights itself fairly soon. In the next issue, Black Canary is again assisting the group and Johnny Thunder is as useless as ever.
![]() |
| If you think I'm going to cover the Invasion From Fairlyand, think again. But do note Johnny's absence from the headshots. |
By the issue after that (All-Star #40), Johnny Thunder is gone, without mention or farewell, and Black Canary is simply a member like everyone else:
![]() |
| You know she's a Real Member now because she got an ASSIGNMENT. |
Now you know how Black Canary joined the JSA (and Johnny Thunder left). Now you know why you have never seen it reprinted (it's stupid and 38 pages long). Now you know that the JSA's greatest foe, the one who killed them all single-handedly and almost did so twice, was an. unnamed security guard at a wax museum.





































































